How the comparison works
What decides a rank, what goes into a price, what the computation assumes and what it leaves out.
Ranking computed on November 2, 2026.
Ranking criteria
A ranking follows one criterion, written above its table. Rows that tie are separated by Return, then by price.
| Sort | Definition |
|---|---|
| My odds | Simulated probability of at least one payout within 12 months, based on your settings. |
| Return | What $1 paid returns at the first payout, on average, failures included. |
| Cost per payout | Average spend to get one payout, rebuying until the first. |
| Break even | Share of purchases that return at least their cost within 12 months. |
| Total price | Public price, activation fee included if the phase is passed. Subscription: monthly price and average cost until the evaluation ends. |
- A row enters the ranking if the firm is active, its price is known, its rules are class A or B and it does not rest on a single record.
- One row per program, at the size closest to the target size, between half and double that size.
- Two rows from one firm with the same rules and the same split count as one: the size closest to the target stays, the smaller one at equal distance, the cheaper one at equal size.
- Three rows at most per firm.
- A gap below the computation error gives the same rank, written with an equals sign. The comparison is always with the first of the group, never with the row next to it.
- Evaluations and instant accounts are ranked apart: an instant account buys its way past the evaluation.
Links with firms
Kara has no contractual or capital link with these firms and receives no payment from them.
Payment
Kara Tools sells trading software. Firms pay it nothing to appear here, and no payment affects the sort.
The price
The price shown is the public price, recorded on the firm’s website on each row’s date.
- Activation
- Due only if the evaluation is passed. It is shown next to the price, and counts in Return and Cost per payout for the share of purchases that pass.
- Subscription
- The price shown is for one month. Return and Cost per payout count the average length of the evaluation.
- Reset
- It is not part of the total price. Only the computation of a year of rebuying uses it.
- Promotions
- A promotion expires and its end date is not published. The current price is shown struck through next to the public price, and the ranking stays on the public price. Firms always on promotion are therefore at a disadvantage.
- Currencies
- Prices in euros and pounds are converted to dollars at the ECB reference rate of October 30, 2026: €1 = $1.117, £1 = $1.34.
Commercial guarantees
They vary from one firm to another: fee refund, scaling plan. The refund counts in Return and Cost per payout when the firm publishes it. The scaling plan is not part of the computation. Each firm’s page gives the detail.
Coverage
The comparison follows 67 firms and 2,448 rows. The list is not exhaustive: other firms exist, and a row followed is not always ranked.
| Reason | Accounts | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Out of size | 128 | Too far from the target size. |
| Missing rule | 220 | A rule that weighs on the result is not published, or not clear enough to simulate. |
| Single source | 7 | A single record, without the firm’s website. |
| Unknown price | 0 | No public price recorded. |
| Same rules | 46 | The same offer is already listed at a closer size. |
| Firm status | 7 | Firm closed, paused or to be checked. |
Listing
A firm enters if it sells a challenge that can be read online. It leaves if it closes. No firm pays to appear here or for its position.
Updates
Records are reviewed by hand on the firms’ websites, at least once a quarter. The first 30 rows of each ranking are reviewed at every release. Each row carries its date.
Color thresholds
A color says a figure crosses a fixed threshold. It does not judge a firm, and it always comes with a figure, a word or an icon.
| Information | Green | Amber | Red | Neutral |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Return | ≥ 2 | 1 to 2 | < 1 | — |
| Break-even rate, against your win rate | Break-even ≤ rate − 2 | From rate − 2 to rate | Break-even > rate | |
| Drawdown type | Static | End-of-day trailing | Intraday trailing | Unknown |
| Firm rule | Allowed | Restricted | Forbidden | To check |
| Reliability | ≥ 75 | 45 to 74 | < 45 | |
| Trustpilot | ≥ 4.5 | 4 to 4.4 | < 4 | No score |
| Fee refund | Yes | No | ||
| Record | Over 90 days | Recent |
My odds has no color threshold: the bar stays green at any value, its length is enough.
What the engine simulates
The engine draws paths, trade after trade, on each account’s rules. The simulated trader always keeps the same behavior.
- Size
- They risk the set percentage, cut below the daily limit if a single stop would breach it, and to the firm’s cap when known. The row shows it.
- Near the floor
- Their stop never goes past the loss floor: they reduce size, and under a tiny margin the account is lost.
- Discipline
- They do not open a trade whose stop would touch the daily limit, they end their day. Only a slipped stop can then breach it.
- Target reached, days missing
- They stop risking and place micro lots until the required number of days. It costs time.
- Target reached, consistency not met
- They carry on at normal risk and cap their day at the allowed share.
- After the evaluation
- The next phase starts on the following trading day.
- Withdrawal ready
- As soon as the amount, the profitable days and consistency are met, they stop and wait for the date. If only the profitable days or consistency are missing, they carry on.
- After a withdrawal
- The balance drops, profitable days and the best day start from zero, unless the firm’s rule says otherwise.
- End
- The path ends when the account is lost, at the set horizon, or at the maximum number of payouts. Profit not withdrawn does not count.
- In the evening
- They close every evening. Balance and equity are therefore equal at the close, and the daily loss basis changes nothing for them. That holds for this trader, not for a swing trader.
What it does not simulate
The danger is not statistical error, it lies in the assumptions. Here is each one, with its effect on the typical account when it is measured.
| Assumption | Direction | Per 100 purchases of the typical account | What the page does |
|---|---|---|---|
| The stated win rate is wrong | Mostly optimistic | At 52%: 17. At 58%: 75. | Range at three points on each row. |
| Fees underestimated | Optimistic | No fees: 70. At 0.10 R: 22. | Setting, markers by style. |
| Trader with no edge | Strong | Coin flip at 2%: 11. | Chance test. |
| Chosen withdrawal threshold | Moves the odds | Withdrawal at +1%: 53. At +5%: 46. | Setting, Return visible. |
| They always cut their day | Optimistic | No stop: 46. With stop: 46. | Switch. |
| Stops respected | Optimistic | No slipped stops: 49. At 3%: 40. | Setting. |
| Horizon | Moves the gain more than the odds | At 6 months: 40. At 24 months: 46. | Every gain carries its horizon. |
| Independent trades | Optimistic | Not measured | Written, not simulated. |
| No overnight positions | Optimistic for a swing trader | Not measured | Written. |
| Same fees in R everywhere | Moves firms | Not measured | Written: spreads are not published. |
| Public price | Penalizes promotions | Not measured | Two prices shown. |
| Fixed gain on each trade | Neutral on average | Not measured | Written: it is what the setting asks for. |
| Contract tiers, leverage, whole sizes | Optimistic at high risk | Not measured | Written. |
| Withdrawal fees | Optimistic | Not measured | Note on the record. |
| Capped total payouts, refused withdrawals | Strong, not quantifiable | Not measured | Never blended into My odds. Reliability and Trustpilot alongside. |
| Starting split for life, profit not withdrawn | Cautious | Not measured | Written. |
| A rule that is too favorable ends up first | Strong, invisible | Not measured | Human review of the top rows at every release. |
What is not simulated: refused payouts, real slippage, overnight positions, contract tiers. Trades are assumed independent.
Data classes
Missing data never favors a firm. A row takes the worst class of its fields, and no assumption is silent.
| Class | Effect | Mark |
|---|---|---|
| A | Ranked, full figure. | None |
| B | Ranked, with the list of its assumptions. | *, and the list on hover |
| C | Simulated, never ranked. | ≈, in gray |
| D | No figure: a rule is missing, the link leads to the source. | Missing rule |
Report an error
An error on a price or a rule: write to support@kara-trading-tools.com, with the name of the row and the link to the source.