10,000 traders win 50% of their trades, at 1:1, risking 2% on a typical 100K account.
10,000 traders win of their trades, at , risking on a typical 100K account.
DAY 0 / 2520 paid0 lost · 0 still in play
17 to 7517 to 75 if your real win rate is three points off
A coin flip.1,145 paid out of 10,000.Can you do better?
Five points more. Half the risk.
Simulation based on your assumptions. This is not a rate observed at the firm, nor a promise of profit. If your real win rate is three points lower, your odds can be cut in half. Trading involves a risk of loss.
10,000 of the ranking's 20,000 draws. Possible gap: one point.
Prop firm simulator: 10,000 virtual traders, one dot per trader
A trader at , , , on the top 3030 accounts.
If your numbers are right: 46 vs 6.
At 0.75% risk, this account rises to 50 out of 100.
Ranked by My odds: simulated probability of at least one payout within 12 months, based on your settings. 284 accounts from 54 firms, not an exhaustive list. Free listing: no firm pays to appear here or for its position.
| Rank | Account | Capital | Rules | My odds | Odds | Return | Total price | Marks | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 100K | 12 · max 12% · day 5% | 60% | 24-87 | 48.9% | ×4.4 | $992 | $599 | |||
| 2 | 100K | 10 · max 12% · day 3% | 56% | 25-81 | 47.9% | ×5.6 | $864 | $481promo $312 | * | ||
| 3 | 100K | 8 + 5 · max 12% · day 4% | 54% | 19-82 | 48.3% | ×6.7 | $729 | $393promo $255 | * | ||
| 4 | 100K | 12 · max 12% · day 3% | 53% | 22-79 | 49.7% | ×3.4 | $1,268 | $666 | |||
| =4 | 100K | 12 · max 12% · day 3% | 53% | 22-79 | 50.3% | ×2.9 | $1,589 | $835promo $585 | |||
| 6 | 100K | 10 + 8 · max 12% · day 4% | 48% | 13-82 | 50.6% | ×3.7 | $1,160 | $555 | |||
| 7 | 100K | 10 · max 7.5% · day 4% | 46% | 21-70 | 49.7% | ×2.4 | $1,411 | $650 | * | ||
| =7 | 100K | 8 + 5 · max 10% · day 5% | 46% | 17-75 | 50.4% | ×3.5 | $1,240 | $569promo $341 | * | ||
| =7 | 100K | 8 + 5 · max 10% · day 5% | 46% | 17-75 | 50.5% | ×3.3 | $1,305 | $599promo $359 | * | ||
| =7 | 100K | 8 + 5 · max 10% · day 5% | 46% | 17-75 | 50.6% | ×3.0 | $1,420 | $652 | |||
| =7 | 100K | 8 + 5 · max 10% · day 5% | 46% | 17-75 | 50.6% | ×2.9 | $1,484 | $681promo $409 | * | ||
| =7 | 100K | 8 + 5 · max 10% · day 5% | 46% | 17-75 | 50.6% | ×3.0 | $1,438 | $660 | |||
| =7 | 100K | 8 + 5 · max 10% · day 5% | 46% | 17-75 | 50.0% | ×4.1 | $650 | $550 | ↺ | ||
| 14 | 100K | 2 · max 6% · day 4% | 45% | 31-60 | 43.2% | ×2.8 | $851 | $4+$489+$489 | $ | ||
| =14 | 100K | 8 + 6 · max 10% · day 5% | 45% | 16-75 | 50.5% | ×3.5 | $1,232 | $549promo $439 | |||
| =14 | 100K | 8 + 6 · max 10% · day 4% | 45% | 15-75 | 50.7% | ×2.4 | $1,823 | $812promo $568 | |||
| 17 | 100K | 10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5% | 44% | 14-75 | 50.5% | ×4.2 | $1,022 | $447 | * | ||
| =17 | 100K | 10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5% | 44% | 14-75 | 50.6% | ×3.8 | $1,136 | $497 | |||
| =17 | 100K | 10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5% | 44% | 14-75 | 50.6% | ×3.4 | $1,255 | $549promo $384 | |||
| =17 | 100K | 10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5% | 44% | 14-75 | 50.6% | ×3.9 | $694 | $539 | ↺ | ||
| =17 | 100K | 10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5% | 44% | 14-75 | 50.6% | ×3.6 | $1,210 | $529 | * | ||
| =17 | 100K | 10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5% | 44% | 14-75 | 50.6% | ×3.6 | $777 | $603promo $490 | ↺ | ||
| =17 | 100K | 10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5% | 44% | 14-75 | 50.7% | ×2.5 | $1,716 | $750promo $375 | ↺ | ||
| =17 | 100K | 10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5% | 44% | 15-75 | 50.6% | ×3.4 | $1,272 | $555promo $389 | |||
| =17 | 100K | 5 + 10 · max 10% · day 5% | 44% | 14-75 | 50.8% | ×2.4 | $1,960 | $855 | * | ||
| =17 | 100K | 10 · max 8% · day 3% | 43% | 19-68 | 50.5% | ×2.4 | $1,735 | $746 | * | ||
| =17 | 100K | 8 + 5 · max 10% · day 3% | 43% | 17-70 | 48.8% | ×3.8 | $419 | $179 | * | ||
| =17 | 100K | 8 + 5 · max 10% · day 3% | 43% | 17-70 | 49.7% | ×2.9 | $559 | $239promo $155 | * | ||
| 29 | 100K | 10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5% | 43% | 13-75 | 50.6% | ×4.0 | $1,290 | $549 | * | ||
| =29 | 100K | 7.5 + 5 · max 9% · day 4.5% | 42% | 15-71 | 50.6% | ×2.8 | $1,405 | $595 | * |
1
Lark Funding1-Step Max 100K · $59960%×4.4
24% to 87% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $992.
Break-even rate: 48.9%.
12 · max 12% · day 5%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
Full page2
AquaFunded+11 Step Flex · $48156%×5.6
25% to 81% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $864.
Break-even rate: 47.9%.
10 · max 12% · day 3%Public price $481, current promotion $312. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Unknown refund: none.
Full page4
FundingPips+21 Step Flex, daily loss 3% · $66653%×3.4
22% to 79% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,268.
Break-even rate: 49.7%.
12 · max 12% · day 3%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
Full page=4
Blueberry Funded+1Flex 1-Step · $83553%×2.9
22% to 79% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,589.
Break-even rate: 50.3%.
12 · max 12% · day 3%Public price $835, current promotion $585. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on October 31, 2026.
Full page7
Finotive Funding+11 Step Challenge · $65046%×2.4
21% to 70% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,411.
Break-even rate: 49.7%.
10 · max 7.5% · day 4%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Unknown refund: none.
Full page=7
Hola Prime+22-Step Prime (Bi-Weekly 80%) · $56946%×3.5
17% to 75% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,240.
Break-even rate: 50.4%.
8 + 5 · max 10% · day 5%Public price $569, current promotion $341. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on October 31, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Withdrawal rules not reviewed: trader's own buffer, 100% withdrawable · Unknown refund: none.
Full page=7
Crypto Fund Trader2 Phases · $66046%×3.0
17% to 75% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,438.
Break-even rate: 50.6%.
8 + 5 · max 10% · day 5%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
Full page=7
FundedNextStellar 2-Step · $55046%×4.1
17% to 75% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $650.
Break-even rate: 50.0%.
8 + 5 · max 10% · day 5%Recorded on October 31, 2026.
↺ Refund: 100% of the price at the first payout.
Full page14
Funded Trading PlusActivation Accounts · $4 +$48945%×2.8
31% to 60% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $851.
Break-even rate: 43.2%.
2 · max 6% · day 4%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
$ Fee on success: $489 due if you pass.
Full page=14
FintokeiProTrader · $54945%×3.5
16% to 75% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,232.
Break-even rate: 50.5%.
8 + 6 · max 10% · day 5%Public price $549, current promotion $439. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on November 1, 2026.
Full page17
Alpha Capital Group+1Alpha Pro 10% On-Demand 50K à 200K · $44744%×4.2
14% to 75% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,022.
Break-even rate: 50.5%.
10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Unknown minimum payout: none.
Full page=17
Atmos Funded2-Step Standard · $54944%×3.4
14% to 75% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,255.
Break-even rate: 50.6%.
10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5%Public price $549, current promotion $384. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on November 1, 2026.
Full page=17
FunderProClassic · $53944%×3.9
14% to 75% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $694.
Break-even rate: 50.6%.
10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
↺ Refund: 100% of the price at the first payout.
Full page=17
Wall Street Funded (WSFunded)Ultra · $52944%×3.6
14% to 75% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,210.
Break-even rate: 50.6%.
10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Unknown refund: none.
Full page=17
FTMOChallenge 2-Step · $60344%×3.6
14% to 75% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $777.
Break-even rate: 50.6%.
10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5%Public price $603, current promotion $490. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on November 1, 2026.
↺ Refund: 100% of the price at the first payout.
Full page=17
Funding Traders2-Step Pro10 · $75044%×2.5
14% to 75% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,716.
Break-even rate: 50.7%.
10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5%Public price $750, current promotion $375. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on November 1, 2026.
↺ Refund: 100% of the price at the second payout.
Full page=17
BrightFunded2-Step Classic · $55544%×3.4
15% to 75% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,272.
Break-even rate: 50.6%.
10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5%Public price $555, current promotion $389. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on November 1, 2026.
Full page=17
Moneta Funded2-Step Challenge 5% / 10% · $85544%×2.4
14% to 75% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,960.
Break-even rate: 50.8%.
5 + 10 · max 10% · day 5%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Unknown refund: none.
Full page=17
Instant FundingOne-Phase PRO · $74643%×2.4
19% to 68% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,735.
Break-even rate: 50.5%.
10 · max 8% · day 3%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Payout days counted on the calendar.
Full page=17
The5ersSummer Plan 2 Steps 8/5 · $17943%×3.8
17% to 70% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $419.
Break-even rate: 48.8%.
8 + 5 · max 10% · day 3%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Unknown minimum days: 0 · Unknown refund: none.
Full page=17
Blue Guardian2 Step Nano · $23943%×2.9
17% to 70% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $559.
Break-even rate: 49.7%.
8 + 5 · max 10% · day 3%Public price $239, current promotion $155. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Unknown refund: none.
Full page29
City Traders Imperium2-Step Challenge · $54943%×4.0
13% to 75% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,290.
Break-even rate: 50.6%.
10 + 5 · max 10% · day 5%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Unknown refund: none.
Full pageSimulation based on your assumptions. This is not a rate observed at the firm, nor a promise of profit. If your real win rate is three points lower, your odds can be cut in half. Trading involves a risk of loss.
20,000 paths per account, computed in advance.
Ranked by My odds: simulated probability of at least one payout within 12 months, based on your settings. 284 accounts from 54 firms, not an exhaustive list. Free listing: no firm pays to appear here or for its position.
18 of 30 accounts do not pay back, on average, at the first payout. An instant account buys its way past the evaluation. Its odds do not compare with those of a challenge at the same price.
| Rank | Account | Capital | Rules | My odds | Odds | Return | Total price | Marks | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 80K | max 6% | 67% | 52-81 | 53.4% | ×0.5 | $5,959 | $3,999 | |||
| 2 | 100K | max 6% · day 6% | 64% | 54-75 | 57.0% | ×0.3 | $7,061 | $4,499promo $3,599 | |||
| 3 | 50K | max 6% · day 3% | 62% | 50-72 | 56.4% | ×0.4 | $2,910 | $1,800 | * | ||
| 4 | 100K | max 6% · day 4% | 61% | 41-76 | 45.5% | ×4.1 | $1,339 | $813 | * | ||
| 5 | 100K | max 6% | 56% | 29-81 | 52.0% | ×0.9 | $2,848 | $1,609 | *↓ | ||
| =5 | 50K | max 6% | 56% | 29-81 | 52.2% | ×0.8 | $1,582 | $894 | *↓ | ||
| 7 | 100K | max 6% · day 5% | 52% | 38-64 | 51.3% | ×0.9 | $2,324 | $1,199promo $839 | * | ||
| 8 | 100K | max 8% · day 5% | 49% | 32-67 | 54.8% | ×0.4 | $9,099 | $4,500 | |||
| =8 | 100K | max 8% · day 8% | 49% | 32-67 | 55.1% | ×0.4 | $8,592 | $4,249 | |||
| =8 | 100K | max 8% · day 4% | 49% | 32-67 | 55.6% | ×0.4 | $10,717 | $5,300 | * | ||
| 11 | 100K | max 6% · day 3% | 45% | 30-59 | 49.0% | ×1.7 | $1,774 | $799 | |||
| =11 | 100K | max 6% · day 3% | 45% | 30-59 | 51.6% | ×0.9 | $2,535 | $1,142promo $571 | |||
| =11 | 50K | max 6% · day 6% | 45% | 33-59 | 57.4% | ×0.3 | $4,759 | $2,139 | |||
| =11 | 50K | max 7% · day 3% | 44% | 30-60 | 50.7% | ×1.1 | $1,628 | $719 | ↺ | ||
| 15 | 100K | max 5% · day 3% | 42% | 31-54 | 48.1% | ×1.5 | $1,540 | $649promo $454 | |||
| =15 | 100K | max 6% · day 3% | 41% | 28-54 | 50.8% | ×1.1 | $2,784 | $1,149promo $575 | * | ||
| 17 | 100K | max 5% · day 3% | 38% | 26-52 | 52.5% | ×0.9 | $3,159 | $1,199promo $959 | |||
| =17 | 100K | max 6% · day 3% | 38% | 24-53 | 53.1% | ×0.8 | $5,314 | $1,999 | |||
| =17 | 100K | max 5% · day 3% | 37% | 26-51 | 50.0% | ×1.7 | $1,348 | $505promo $328 | * | ||
| 20 | 100K | max 3.6% · day 2.5% | 37% | 28-49 | 54.9% | ×0.5 | $2,305 | $850 | * | ||
| 21 | 50K | max 4% · day 3% | 35% | 26-46 | 48.3% | ×1.6 | $821 | $289 | |||
| 22 | 100K | max 5% · day 3% | 34% | 23-47 | 51.1% | ×1.4 | $1,471 | $499 | * | ||
| =22 | 100K | max 6% · day 3% | 33% | 20-50 | 49.7% | ×2.0 | $2,725 | $899 | ↺ | ||
| 24 | 100K | max 4% · day 2% | 32% | 22-43 | 51.9% | ×0.8 | $1,763 | $563promo $282 | * | ||
| =24 | 50K | max 4% | 31% | 23-42 | 60.9% | ×0.3 | $1,590 | $499promo $50 | |||
| =24 | 50K | max 4% · day 2% | 31% | 21-46 | 54.3% | ×0.4 | $2,252 | $700promo $70 | * | ||
| 27 | 100K | max 3.2% | 30% | 21-42 | 55.0% | ×0.5 | $2,975 | $900 | |||
| =27 | 50K | max 4% · day 2% | 30% | 20-41 | 50.9% | ×1.1 | $950 | $284promo $170 | * | ||
| 29 | 100K | max 4% · day 2% | 29% | 20-39 | 50.5% | ×1.4 | $2,745 | $785 | |||
| 30 | 50K | max 4% | 27% | 18-39 | 49.0% | ×1.7 | $550 | $150 | * |
1
City Traders ImperiumDirect Funding · $3,99967%×0.5
52% to 81% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $5,959.
Break-even rate: 53.4%.
max 6%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
Full page2
Funded Trading PlusInstant Funding · $4,49964%×0.3
54% to 75% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $7,061.
Break-even rate: 57.0%.
max 6% · day 6%Public price $4,499, current promotion $3,599. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on November 1, 2026.
Full page3
Wall Street Funded (WSFunded)+1Instant Standard · $1,80062%×0.4
50% to 72% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $2,910.
Break-even rate: 56.4%.
max 6% · day 3%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Unknown minimum payout: none.
Full page4
Instant FundingIF Micro PRO · $81361%×4.1
41% to 76% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,339.
Break-even rate: 45.5%.
max 6% · day 4%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Payout days counted on the calendar.
Full page5
The Trading Pit+1CFD Instant 100K · $1,60956%×0.9
29% to 81% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $2,848.
Break-even rate: 52.0%.
max 6%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Payout days counted on the calendar.
↓ Risk cut to 0.5% on this account.
Full page7
FTUKInstant Funding · $1,19952%×0.9
38% to 64% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $2,324.
Break-even rate: 51.3%.
max 6% · day 5%Public price $1,199, current promotion $839. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Payout days counted on the calendar · Unknown minimum payout: none.
Full page8
Lark FundingInstant 100K · $4,50049%×0.4
32% to 67% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $9,099.
Break-even rate: 54.8%.
max 8% · day 5%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
Full page=8
FXIFY+2Instant Funding Standard · $4,24949%×0.4
32% to 67% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $8,592.
Break-even rate: 55.1%.
max 8% · day 8%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
Full page=8
Moneta FundedInstant Funding Pro · $5,30049%×0.4
32% to 67% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $10,717.
Break-even rate: 55.6%.
max 8% · day 4%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Unknown refund: none.
Full page11
FunderProInstant · $79945%×1.7
30% to 59% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,774.
Break-even rate: 49.0%.
max 6% · day 3%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
Full page=11
Top One Trader+1Instant Funding · $1,14245%×0.9
30% to 59% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $2,535.
Break-even rate: 51.6%.
max 6% · day 3%Public price $1,142, current promotion $571. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on November 1, 2026.
Full page=11
RZR FundedInstant Funding · $2,13945%×0.3
33% to 59% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $4,759.
Break-even rate: 57.4%.
max 6% · day 6%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
Full page=11
ThinkCapital+1Bolt Flex · $71944%×1.1
30% to 60% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,628.
Break-even rate: 50.7%.
max 7% · day 3%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
↺ Refund: 100% of the price at the third payout.
Full page15
Atmos FundedInstant Funding · $64942%×1.5
31% to 54% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,540.
Break-even rate: 48.1%.
max 5% · day 3%Public price $649, current promotion $454. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on November 1, 2026.
Full page=15
Orion FundedOrion Zero · $1,14941%×1.1
28% to 54% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $2,784.
Break-even rate: 50.8%.
max 6% · day 3%Public price $1,149, current promotion $575. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Unknown refund: none.
Full page=17
AquaFundedInstant Funding Standard · $50537%×1.7
26% to 51% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,348.
Break-even rate: 50.0%.
max 5% · day 3%Public price $505, current promotion $328. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Unknown refund: none.
Full page20
Funded Futures Network+1MAX Standard Skip the Eval · $85037%×0.5
28% to 49% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $2,305.
Break-even rate: 54.9%.
max 3.6% · day 2.5%Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Payout days counted on the calendar.
Full page24
Top One FuturesIgnite Instant Funding · $56332%×0.8
22% to 43% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,763.
Break-even rate: 51.9%.
max 4% · day 2%Public price $563, current promotion $282. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on November 1, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Payout days counted on the calendar.
Full page=24
Funded Futures Family+1S2F Accelerate 50K · $49931%×0.3
23% to 42% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $1,590.
Break-even rate: 60.9%.
max 4%Public price $499, current promotion $50. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on November 1, 2026.
Full page=27
FundedNext+1Direct · $28430%×1.1
20% to 41% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $950.
Break-even rate: 50.9%.
max 4% · day 2%Public price $284, current promotion $170. This ranking uses the public price. Recorded on October 31, 2026.
* Computed with assumptions: Payout days counted on the calendar.
Full page29
Blueberry FundedInstant Lite · $78529%×1.4
20% to 39% if your real win rate is three points off.
Cost per payout: $2,745.
Break-even rate: 50.5%.
max 4% · day 2%Recorded on October 31, 2026.
Full pageSimulation based on your assumptions. This is not a rate observed at the firm, nor a promise of profit. If your real win rate is three points lower, your odds can be cut in half. Trading involves a risk of loss.
20,000 paths per account, computed in advance.
How this ranking is built.
How the comparison worksSort: My odds, then Return, then price. One row per program, at the size closest to 100K, between 50K and 200K. Two rows from one firm with the same rules and the same split count as one: the size closest to 100K stays, the smaller one at equal distance, the cheaper one at equal size. Three rows at most per firm. Settings: 55%, 1:1, 1%, 2 trades per day, 0.05 R fees, withdrawal at +5%, 1% slipped stops, 12 months. 284 accounts ranked, 408 set aside: out of size 128, missing rule 220, single source 7, unknown price 0, same rules 46, firm status 7. Public prices, recorded on each row’s date. Kara Tools sells trading software. Kara has no contractual or capital link with these firms and receives no payment from them. No payment affects the sort.
The account avoids the worst. Your win rate decides the rest.
At the same settings, accounts range from 8 to 44 out of 100: picking the account rules out the worst. Among the top 30, 18 points separate them. Three points of win rate, either way, move 59.
Same traders. Same draws. 52% becomes 58%.
Simulation based on your assumptions. This is not a rate observed at the firm, nor a promise of profit. If your real win rate is three points lower, your odds can be cut in half. Trading involves a risk of loss.
Same price, 16 to 44 out of 100.
Under $300, median odds are 9 out of 100. At $550, 37. Beyond that, price adds almost nothing. And at the same price, the gap stays huge.
Public price, no promotion. Firms always on promotion are at a disadvantage.
Simulation based on your assumptions. This is not a rate observed at the firm, nor a promise of profit. If your real win rate is three points lower, your odds can be cut in half. Trading involves a risk of loss.
The chance test
On 88 of 284 accounts, a coin flip at 2% returns more than it costs, on average.
And 91% of these purchases get nothing. The average lives off those who pass.
On these accounts, losing on average over many purchases means doing worse than chance.
This is not advice. The expectancy comes from a loss capped at the account price and a payout that exceeds it. It is paid for by a very high probability of getting nothing.
8 accounts have their break-even rate off this axis.
Simulation based on your assumptions. This is not a rate observed at the firm, nor a promise of profit. If your real win rate is three points lower, your odds can be cut in half. Trading involves a risk of loss.
The right risk depends on the question.
More risk means lower odds per account, and accounts settled faster.
My odds on one account
My return on one account, over 12 months
My year, rebuying after each failure
12.7 accounts bought
0.75% for the odds. 1% for the gain per account. 3% for the year, if you rebuy 12.7 accounts.
Too low, the target does not arrive within the year. Too high, the account blows up.
Simulation based on your assumptions. This is not a rate observed at the firm, nor a promise of profit. If your real win rate is three points lower, your odds can be cut in half. Trading involves a risk of loss.
This figure rests on your word.
Three points off on your win rate can cut your odds in half. Connect an account: your positions flow into the Kara journal on their own. You see your real win rate, your real RR against your intended RR, and your expectancy per trade. Then you rerun this simulation with those numbers.
| Your settings | Stated | Measured |
|---|---|---|
| Win rate | 55% | to measure |
| Reward / risk | 1:1 | to measure |
| Risk | 1% | to measure |
What moves the figure.
A simulator is worth its assumptions. Here they are, sorted by weight, on the typical account.
- Your win rate ±3 points52% · 1758% · 75
- Fees 0 and 0.10 R0 R · 700.10 R · 22
- Slipped stops 0 and 3%0% · 493% · 40
- Withdrawal level +1 and +5%+1% · 53+5% · 46
- Horizon 6 and 24 months6 months · 4024 months · 46
- Trades per day 1 and 51 · 405 · 45
- Disciplinewithout · 46with · 46
- Account choice, 10th to 90th percentile844
What is not simulated: refused payouts, real slippage, overnight positions, contract tiers. Trades are assumed independent. How the comparison works
Simulation based on your assumptions. This is not a rate observed at the firm, nor a promise of profit. If your real win rate is three points lower, your odds can be cut in half. Trading involves a risk of loss.
Questions we get asked
How the comparison worksAre these odds the firms' real rates?
Why does my result move so much with three points of win rate?
Is more risk better?
I don't know my real numbers.
Did a firm pay to be here?
Why isn't this account listed?
Why isn't the promo price used by default?
What isn't simulated?
Are my settings sent anywhere?
Put your real numbers into this simulator.
14 days free, no commitment. Windows, Linux, browser.
Measure my real numbers